Git Checkout vs Git Switch: What’s the Difference and Which Should You Use?
Ah, git checkout
. The jack-of-all-trades, the Swiss Army knife, the “one command to rule them all” in the Git world. For years, this has been our main tool for switching branches. We use it to restore files, create branches, and detach HEADs (not exactly). But let’s face it: multitasking isn’t always a good thing.
If you’ve ever found yourself wondering, “Did I just restore a file or switch branches?”, then congratulations—you’ve been a victim of git checkout
’s overly ambitious nature.
That’s why, starting with Git 2.23, the Git wizards blessed us with two new commands: git switch
and git restore
. They’re clearer, safer, and designed to simplify your life. In this post, I’ll show you why these commands are the heroes your Git workflow needs—and how to start using them today.
By the end of this post, you’ll not only know when to use git checkout
vs git switch
but also how these commands can supercharge your Git workflow. Spoiler alert: One of them might become your new favorite tool.
Why Did Git Break Up With git checkout?
Let’s start with a confession: git checkout
is a bit of an overachiever. It does everything. Need to switch branches? Check out a specific commit? Create a new branch? Restore files? git checkout
is your go-to.
Here’s what git checkout
used to juggle:
- Switching branches.
- Creating new branches.
- Restoring files.
- Checking out specific commits.
The result? Ambiguity and a whole lot of human error. Have you ever tried to restore a file but accidentally switched branches? Or detached your HEAD without knowing what just happened? Yep, we’ve all been there.
Git’s solution was simple: split git checkout
into two specialized commands:
git switch
for switching and creating branches.git restore
for restoring files or working tree states.
Now, instead of one multitasking command, we have tools that are purpose-built—and far less likely to make you pull your hair out.
git checkout vs git switch: Let’s Settle This
Here’s where the magic happens. Let’s compare how these commands stack up in common scenarios.
1. Switching Branches
- The Old Way (
git checkout
):git checkout feature-branch
Does the job, but it’s easy to accidentally restore files if you’re not careful. - The New Way (
git switch
):git switch feature-branch
Straightforward and unambiguous. You’re just switching branches—nothing more, nothing less.
2. Creating a New Branch
- The Old Way (
git checkout
):git checkout -b new-branch
- The New Way (
git switch
):git switch -c new-branch
Why git switch
is Better: The -c
flag explicitly says, “Hey, I’m creating a branch here!” It’s clear, concise, and reduces confusion.
3. Restoring Files
This is where git restore
truly shines.
- The Old Way (
git checkout
):git checkout HEAD~1 myfile.txt
Did you just restore a file? Switch branches? Detach your HEAD? Who knows? - The New Way (
git restore
):git restore myfile.txt
Why git restore
Wins: It’s laser-focused. If you’re restoring a file, use git restore
. No side effects, no guessing games.
Why This Matters for Your Workflow
Still not convinced? Let’s talk about why switching to git switch
and git restore
is more than just a nice-to-have.
1. Fewer Mistakes
With git switch
and git restore
, you can’t accidentally restore files when you meant to switch branches—or vice versa. Each command has one job, so there’s less room for error.
2. Cleaner Commands
Your intent is crystal clear. When you type git switch
, everyone knows you’re switching branches. When you type git restore
, it’s obvious you’re fixing files. It makes your workflow more readable for both you and your team.
3. Future-Proofing
Git’s not-so-subtle nudges (“Did you mean git switch
?”) are a sign of things to come. git switch
and git restore
are the future, so it’s better to get comfortable with them now.
How to Start Using git switch and git restore
Ready to level up your Git game? Here’s how to make the switch (pun intended):
1. Update Your Git Version
If you’re not seeing these commands, you’re probably running an ancient version of Git. Time to update:
sudo apt update && sudo apt install git # Linux
brew install git # macOS
2. Replace git checkout
in Your Workflow
Next time you need to switch branches or restore files, use the new commands:
git switch main
git switch -c new-branch
git restore myfile.txt
3. Create Aliases for Convenience
Save some keystrokes by setting up aliases:
git config --global alias.sw switch
git config --global alias.re restore
Now you can type git sw
and git re
like a true Git ninja.
Final Thoughts
Look, I get it. Change is hard, and using git switch and git restore is not just a trend. It is about clarity, efficiency, and improving your workflow for the future.
So the next time you catch yourself typing git checkout
, stop. Ask yourself: Am I switching branches or restoring files? Then use the right tool for the job.
Your future self—and your team—will thank you. Now go ahead and give these commands a shot. You might even start enjoying Git (well, almost).
You may also like 7 Secrets to Writing GitHub Issues That Get Bugs Fixed Fast